Posted on Leave a comment

Javier Zamora’s Solito: A Memoir Like No Other

Although frequenting bookstores is a great hobby of mine, I try my best not to buy more books. For one thing, I have too many books to read at home that I haven’t gotten to yet. And my other reason for banning myself from impulsive book purchases is the fact that I can, and should, make more usage of libraries that abound nearby. Yet, I recently bought myself another book: Javier Zamora’s Solito.

I have a tendency to read genres I naturally gravitate towards, like historical fiction, classics, and young adult fantasies. So getting a copy of Solito: A Memoir was an out of the ordinary decision. (And, might I add, choosing to read the nonfiction for a book club amidst a jam-packed schedule was almost a form of self-torture.)

Despite the stacks of unread books haunting me at home along with the unusuality and impracticality of my decision, I so, so do not regret it.

Because Javier Zamora’s Solito is a memoir like no other.

Synopsis of Solito:

Solito narrates the true story of Javier Zamora when he was just nine-years-old and the journey he made from El Salvadaor across Guatemala and Mexico to the United States to reunite with his parents who had migrated before him. It details Javier’s life before, during, and after the long, dangerous “trip,” the people he had to leave behind as well as those he met along the way.

Photo by Beau Horyza.

Reflections

I didn’t know what to expect from this book other than the fact that it was going to be a story about a boy who immigrates to the states. Never did I imagine how detailed, how honest the account was going to be. Not only did it record every bit of the innocence and vulnerability of Javier Zamora’s younger self, but also it zoomed in on the immigrant experience, specifically those of migrants who cross the U.S.-Mexican border. It revealed how illegal immigration isn’t just a term and concept but a streak of hope for people who aren’t simply “criminals” or “lawbreakers” but rather individuals trying to survive. Many of whom, like Javier, Chino, Patricia, and Carla, are trying to reunite with their families in the land of opportunity and hope.

For someone like me who doesn’t know anyone who has crossed the border to come to the states or have read any accounts detailing such journeys, Solito was, to say the least, eye-opening. I never knew the details of these long journeys, and how they were matters of life or death, success or failure, joy or despair, and reunion or separation.

One of my fellow book club member pointed out that this story focuses on one boy and the people around him, which is just a small fraction of the countless undocumented immigrants and numerous migrants who don’t make it to their desired destinations. Her statement made me realize how many other stories of success, failure, misfortune, and grief we don’t know about.

Photo by Lisha Riabinina.

Innocence of a Child

Photo by Aaron Burden.

What was painful to notice was the innocence of the author before the great journey and his loss of it afterwards. The nine-year-old Javier refers to his upcoming journey to the states as a “trip.” That’s what all the adults around him referred it to. He knows neither better nor what to expect.

But slowly, the “trip” becomes more than just a trip Javier embarks on to reunite with his parents. It’s saying good-bye to everything he loves, his home and family in El Salvador, to his friends, school, and everything he knew all his life. Suddenly meeting a group of strangers who he needs to depend on and pretend to be families with. Riding hours-long bus and boat rides. Living like a shadow hiding from the locals, stuck inside some dark shelters. Pretending to be Mexican, getting caught and having guns pointed at by soldiers. Walking across deserts for days, under the scorching sun without water and in the middle of the freezing night.

And Loss There Of

Initially, Javier repeatedly refers to the “cadejito.” According to his grandfather, this legendary creature would protect and guide Javier. He prays to it throughout the journey (for instance, on page 79 and 82).

But on page 323, Javier says to himself:

“Last time, I listened for Cadejo’s whistle; now I know for sure he doesn’t exist. Bad things keep happening. He’s just a myth. Just like Marcelo, Cajedo is full of lies. If Cadejo was real, we wouldn’t have gotten caught. Patricia wouldn’t have gotten hurt. Coco Liso would still be here with us. Our prayers haven’t helped either.”

It was heartbreaking to see this transition, from Javier believing in the cadejo to his losing faith and innocence. To watch this young boy (more sensitive than an average nine-year-old per description, I think) undergo hardship after hardship that is overwhelming even to an adult.

Photo by Tim Marshall.

Beautiful Imagery

Photo by Tom Gainor.

Javier Zamora immerses the readers into his deepest memories not only through the raw details but also through his talented use of imagery.

I mean, just take a look at this scene where Javier parts ways with his grandfather:

We stand by the road, the banana trees on either side, raindrops still on the leaves, sliding down, dropping to the ground. It rained earlier in the day, but these drops haven’t evaporated. Grandpa’s eyes are doing the same, trying to hold his tears inside their corners (Zamora 71).

And his descriptions of the desert are beautiful and ingenious at the same time:

Everything is awake. The moon lights the ground silver and blue. Wispy clouds dance in the sky, white ones that look like silk. With this wind and with this lighting – the blue, the grays – it feels like the bottom of the ocean… The grass is seaweed. The cactuses are coral. We’re looking through a submarine’s small circular window… On top, the clouds are sea foam. The ground sparkles with seashells and pearls (Zamora 298).

Child’s Imagination

Another thing that struck out to me (and I appreciated very much) were the imaginative descriptions from the nine-year-old Javier. Just take a look at these cleverly brilliant descriptions from the young boy’s perspective:

The stars begin to dot the sky. I like to think there’s a giant holding the earth in one hand, a needle in his other hand, poking the sky there, there, and there – (Zamora 135).

And I couldn’t help but smile at the names Javier gave to different cacti when he spotted them during his trek across the desert: “the Spikeys,” “Cheerleader bush” with flowers like “little yellow pom-poms,” “Crayon bush,” and “Paint-Roller Fuzzies,” “Mascara-Brush Fuzzies,” “Thorny Tentacles,” and “skinny green smooth tree” that Javier nicknames “SGS tree.”

Photo by Joe Cook.

There are countless other examples of uniquely clever imagery that Javier uses throughout the book, like when he describes the line of migrants as “the centipede” or when he says that cactuses that look like people “rise from the dirt like giant dark-green Cheetos” (331).

But sometimes, they were gut-wrenching to read, like when he describes the people in prison, including himself, as “monkeys”:

The monkeys in here stare, they sleep, they doze. This cage. This silent and stinky room. The monkeys next to the door wait for their names to be called (248).

Theme of Loneliness

Photo by Majestic Lukas.

Though my post is getting a bit long, I must point out what I felt was one of the most important themes of this book: loneliness. The book starts with a lonely Javier. Despite his being with his grandparents, aunt Mali, friends and relatives, he naturally and understandably longs for his parents constantly.

And his loneliness resurfaces when he has to travel with a group of strangers by himself. He holds his pillow in one arm, pretending the pillow is his Mom or aunt Mali (78). The young Javier also repeatedly mentions how he wants to hug, saying that he wants to “hug anyone like Coyote hugged us for good luck” (201)

I think this quote best shows the acute loneliness he experienced during the long and difficult journey:

I want to cuddle her [aunt Mali] right now. Look at the stars and be far away from these people…I hate watching Patricia and Carla help each other before bed. Patricia braiding and unbraiding her daughter’s hair. I want that with Mom. With Mali. I just want a hug (183).

With all the hardships and drama that ensued, I honestly forgot about this major theme and was busy following Javier’s journey, rooting for him and the people around him as they repeatedly failed to rejoin their families in “La USA.” But the theme dawned on me again when this young boy named a certain type of cactus as “the Lonelies” (217) and when he wished not to part from strangers who had become a true family:

I want to take my new family with me to California, learn how to tie my shoes and show Chino I can do it like him. Chino, my older brother I never had… I love them. I really love them. A pond, a lake in my eyes. I don’t want to let go. None of us wants to let go. A river (372-73).

Integration of the Spanish Language

Lastly but certainly not least is the usage of Spanish throughout the book. Because I had studied some Spanish, it wasn’t difficult to understand most of the time but I did have to look up online sometimes to figure out what Javier and the people around him were saying. But I think the implementation of Spanish in dialogue as well as in Javier’s internal thoughts (like the word “también” and “La USA”) made this memoir all the more real, easy to immerse into. And I think the Spanish phrases and words, even the punctuations, are great integrations that honor the author’s cultural background and heritage.

Photo by Nicole Geri.

Lasting Impact

My book club leader told us that Solito stayed with her for a long time after her first reading of it, and it led her to designate it as our first book club book of the year.

I can confidently say that it has left such a strong impression on me as well, that it has expanded my understanding of the immigrant experience. It stayed with me so strongly even after I finished that I had to visit an El Salvadoran restaurant and mull over it while eating pupusas:

Avocado salad and pupusas at Cafe Platano.
Pupusas cut in halves:
Queso con Loroco (Cheese and Salvadoran flower) and Frijoles con Queso (House black beans & cheese)

And I’m pretty sure that Javier Zamora’s memoir will leave something in you as well.

Conclusion

Javier Zamora’s Solito: A Memoir is a powerfully moving, achingly raw account of a nine-year-old boy. It’s a collection of memories of longing, pain, and loneliness, so vivid and overwhelming even to adults. It forever changes the reader, whether by enlightening, moving, or just leaving a mark – an impression that lingers even long after.

Photo by Tim Umphreys.

P.S. The afterward of the book was fascinating to read, as Javier Zamora shares what his parents had experienced while he was going through the dangerous journey. And it was so touching to read that he wrote this memoir in hopes of reuniting with Chino, Patricia, and Carla.

P.P.S. HERE‘s a video of Javier reading from Solito and HERE is one of his talking about the memoir.

P.P.P.S. The Salvadoran restaurant I visited is called Cafe Platano in Berkeley, CA. Their pupusas and avocado salad were delicious! 😋


Posted on Leave a comment

A Wizard of Earthsea: One of the Best Fantasy Novels of All Time

If you think “fantasy,” what novels pop up in your mind? J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings? C.S. Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia? Or more recent works like J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series and Game of Thrones by George R.R. Martin? These authors are definitely the big names of fantasy with their masterpieces made into widely successful film/TV adaptations.

Dragons, the quintessential element of fantasy. Photo by Sean Thomas.

But have you heard of Ursula K. Le Guin’s Earthsea novels?

If you haven’t, you’re missing out on the most magical, critically-acclaimed fantasy series of all time that’s criminally overlooked by the mass. Allow me to introduce you to Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea.

A Wizard of Earthsea: Tale of Wisdom

This photo would make the perfect movie poster for A Wizard of Earthsea.
Photo by Trevor McKinnon.

A Wizard of Earthsea is the first novel of The Earthsea Cycle, a series of six novels written by Ursula K. Le Guin. Published back in 1968, the book narrates the story of a great wizard named Sparrowhawk, before he became dragonlord and Archmage of all of Earthsea. Le Guin explains in the afterword of the 2012 edition (published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt) that she got the idea for the book after imagining what it would have been like for wizards such as Merlin and Gandalf to learn to be wizards. And A Wizard of Earthsea is just that: how Sparrowhawk, aka Ged, came to be a great wizard, of when he was young and yet a “fool kid.”

The 2012 edition of A Wizard of Earthsea published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
It includes the author’s afterword.

One gets to see the main character, Sparrowhawk/Ged, grow from a young, impatient boy from the island of Gont to a wise, thoughtful wizard after unleashing an evil shadow onto the world while meddling with ancient spells at the School for Wizards. Running away from the dark unnamed being that hunts him, he learns from his mistake and pride, eventually setting forth to face the evil to do what must be done. It’s a magical tale of growth filled with nuggets of wisdom that only come from someone who’s lived long enough to know the ways of the world or insightful enough to understand one or two things about how life works.

It’s not flashy or action-packed, although there are enough adventures throughout. Unlike many of today’s wild, fast-paced novels, A Wizard of Earthsea is a calm, peaceful journey of a reading with irresistible charm and intrigue. And while novels popular with the masses these days are like cheap fast-food with little nutritional value, Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea is like a healthy, well-cooked meal to enjoy with ample amount of time.

A Wizard of Earthsea will take you on a mesmerizing journey across the isles and seas of Earthsea. Photo by François Genon.

The World of Earthsea

Another beauty of Le Guin‘s A Wizard of Earthsea is the incredible worldbuilding. As you follow the protagonist, Ged, on his voyages to the different isles of Earthsea, the world genuinely feels more than some fictional creation. Le Guin crafted the world so well with her descriptions and explanations that Earthsea feels like it’s part of the world we live in, tucked away in some part of the world not well known yet.

The world of Earthsea drawn by the author herself. From the 2012 edition.

As opposed to some other fantasy novels I’ve read lately (*cough* Lightlark *cough.* To see what I mean, check out my Lightlark posts HERE.) the world of Earthsea makes sense. It make so much sense that I buy into the world Le Guin created, so much to the point that it feels like a real world I haven’t explored yet. Her descriptions of the isles and the seas, the people of the different parts of Earthsea don’t confuse me, despite the presence of magic, wizards, and dragons. And not only is her worldbuilding easy to understand, consistent and unique, but it’s also deep.

Here’s what I mean:

True Names of Things

In the world of Earthsea, there is the Old Speech and New Speech, much like how there are Old and modern English. (And like how all languages today have their ancient and modern counterparts.) For wizards to use magic, they must use the true names of things in the Old Speech. As Le Guin explains on page 54, “magic consists in this, the true naming of a thing.”

Here’s how the Master Namer, Kurremkarmerruk, of the School for Wizards explains the principle:

"But magic, true magic, is worked only by those beings who speak the Hardic tongue of Earthsea, or the Old Speech from which it grew. That is the language dragons speak, and the language Segoy spoke who made the islands of the world, and the language of our lays and songs, spells, enchantments, and invocations. Its words lie hidden and changed among our Hardic words."
- From A Wizard of Earthsea by Ursula K. Le Guin. Page 54-55.
Photo by Cristian Escobar.

Real Names

In accordance to this principle of true names, the people of Earthsea have “real names” that they cannot share with anyone but close friends and families they trust:

"No one knows a man's true name but himself and his namer. He may choose at length to tell it to his brother, or his wife, or his friend, yet even those few will never use it where any third person may hear it. In front of other people they will, like other people, call him by his use-name, his nickname... Who knows a man's name, holds that man's life in his keeping." 
- Le Guin 81-82. 
Photo by Clément Falize.

Danger of Shapeshifting

Just listen to this excellent explanation as to why shapeshifting is extremely dangerous to wizards:

"As a boy, Ogion like all boys had thought it would be a very pleasant game to take by art-magic whatever shape one liked, man or beast, tree or cloud, and so to play at a thousand beings. But as a wizard he had learned the price of the game, which is the peril of losing one's self, playing away the truth. The longer a man stays in a form not his own, the greater this peril."
- Le Guin 147-148. 
Photo by Igor Rodrigues.

These ideas, including the power of names, the true names of different things and people, and the danger of shapeshifting, make such great sense and are kept consistent throughout the entire novel that with the map, Earthsea feels as real as clusters of unexplored islands in the middle of the Pacific:

Photo of map of Earthsea from the 1984 edition of A Wizard of Earthsea published by Bantam.

Conclusion

A Wizard of Earthsea has all the elements of true fantasy: magic, dragons and quests that span across seas. It’s a treat to follow Ged on his journeys from one isle to another, using the map illustrated and provided by the author herself. But unlike your conventional fantasy books, Earthsea shows paths a young boy takes to become the great wizard that he later becomes. Through his grave mistake and subsequent trials, Ged learns to face his fears, ultimately overcoming them to become whole as he masters the darkness within.

🧙‍♂️🦅🌠

A Wizard of Earthsea exudes much wisdom about life, offers plenty of suspense from the existence of “the shadow,” and bewitches readers with flawless, deep worldbuilding. It is a masterfully written book that deserves its spot right beside the biggest titles of fantasy literature.

It’s one of the best fantasy novels of all time.

Photo by Wenhao Ryan.

P.S. The next Earthsea novel is called The Tombs of Atuan. It even won a Newbery Award in 1972!

The Tombs of Atuan with copies of A Wizard of Earthsea.
Photo of the back cover of A Wizard of Earthsea (2012).

I can’t wait to read all the sequels. I have a feeling that they’re all going to be stellar like A Wizard of Earthsea.

P.P.S. Learn more about the incredible mind behind Earthsea, author Ursula K. Le Guin, by visiting her official website HERE.


Posted on Leave a comment

Lightlark Overlays (Official Preorder Gift) + Final Commentary

It’s finally here! I received my preorder gift from Abrams Books: the six custom page overlays of characters from Alex Aster’s Lightlark:

The six overlays! Illustrated by the talented @kalisamiii

The overlays came with this card with the following message from the author:

Which has illustrations of the six rulers on the back, along with the prophecy from Lightlark:

Lightlark Overlays

I had to wait a few more weeks after receiving the book on August 24th for these overlays. Though I wished it had shipped with my preordered book, now I’m just happy to have gotten them! Here they are placed inside Lightlark. Aren’t they just stunning?

🥀 Isla Crown, the main protagonist of Lightlark.
Ruler of Wildling.
🌌 Grimshaw, aka ruler of Nightshade.
1 of the 2 love interests of Isla Crown.
☁ King Azul of Skyling.
☀ King Oro aka the Sunling ruler who is also the King of Lightlark. The other love interest of Isla Crown.
🌙 Cleo, the ruler of Moonling, who hates Isla Crown.
🌟 Celeste, ruler of Starlings and Isla’s best friend.

Kalisami did such a great job depicting each of the Lightlark rulers! They look just as they’re supposed to look, based on the descriptions from the book. And I love how she added in the different elements behind each ruler to show what powers they have.

Final Comments on Alex Aster’s Lightlark

Photo by Annie Spratt.

As someone who actually preordered Lightlark and read it, I can say that I enjoyed reading the book. Though it wasn’t the best YA fantasy I’ve ever read or the best piece of fiction, I liked reading about the different realms, albeit some confusing parts that I still don’t fully get.

I especially enjoyed reading the plot twist. I knew something was coming but I certainly did not expect it to have unfolded the way it did. The last 100 pages or so were stunning!

However, I do think that the book was marketed with misleading information. Though it didn’t affect me much as I didn’t buy the book hoping it to be like The Hunger Games or A Court of Thorns and Roses, I can see why many people were/are upset. As someone who followed Alex Aster on Instagram for months, I did notice that some of the parts or quotes that were advertised for Lightlark weren’t in the novel.

Aside from the false advertisement and some editorial mistakes, Lightlark can be a great introductory novel for readers who haven’t read YA fantasy. Something readers can read before jumping into the world of YA fantasy.

Anyways, I’m happy to have read it, to have attended the wonderful Moonling event in San Francisco and to have these overlays to keep:

What are your thoughts on Lightlark?


P.S. To read about the Moonling event I attended in San Francisco, click HERE.

P.P.S. For the other preorder gift from Abrams Books (i.e. the sneak peek), check out the post HERE.

Posted on Leave a comment

Lightlark Book Review & Moonling Event in San Francisco

Lightlark by Alex Aster

Photo by Annie Spratt.

If you’re an active social media user and an avid reader, chances are, you’ve heard of Lightlark. It’s the young adult fantasy novel written by Alex Aster, who has launched it through her famous BookToks. Her videos have garnered so much support that the cover for Lightlark was revealed in New York’s Time Square! I don’t use TikTok, but I do use Instagram, where the reels about the “BookTok Phenomenon” trickled down to my feed.

I usually don’t buy a book I haven’t read from the bookstore (I prefer going to the library first), let alone preorder something that hasn’t even been published yet. But the synopsis for Lightlark was so intriguing that I couldn’t resist preordering a copy from Barnes & Noble. I was so impatient to read the novel that I preordered it three months before its official release date (August 23rd, 2022) for the sneak peek. (For the review of the sneak peek, click HERE.)

And AT LAST! I received my copy of Lightlark last Wednesday, a day after the official release. (I’m still waiting for my 6 overlays that are being shipped separately.)

Different Reviews Online

Photo by Luke Pennystan.

After finishing the first five chapters given as a reward for the preorder, I was a little worried about Lightlark, to be honest. Because while its synopsis was as intriguing as advertised, with the six rulers and this island that appears every 100 years for the deadly games, the world building was confusing. But as I had only read the first five chapters, I refrained from judging and remained hopeful that it would only get better.

Meanwhile, influencers who’ve read the entire book before everyone else were raving about it. So I wasn’t too worried about Lightlark. Alas, negative reviews started to pop up on Goodreads. There probably were people who unfairly gave out 1 star reviews without actually having read the book. But as I tiptoed around spoilers, I noticed that there were also some people who actually read it and didn’t like it.

I couldn’t wait to finish the book myself and see who was telling the truth: the raving fans on Instagram or the disapproving reviewers on Goodreads.

Reading Lightlark!

My Predictions

The front cover behind the jacket. I believe it was 1 of the 2 mock covers that TikTok users got to vote on.

Here were some predictions I made as I read:

  • Terra, Poppy, and Celeste are a little sus. The way Terra and Poppy have her locked away is a bit too much. And Celeste – Isla Crown, our protagonist, only knew her for 3 years but they were practically best friends, no, “sisters” (page 62). I don’t think 3 year is enough time to become sisters with someone, let alone a competing ruler.
  • Are Celeste and Cleo related? ‘Cause the moon and stars belong together, and their names are a bit similar, both starting with a “C.” Maybe they’re sisters? I’ve been seeing on the author’s IG stories how influencers and bloggers are blown away by “twists.” Plus the back of the book inside the jacket says “There are lies and liars all around you.” I have a strong feeling that Isla Crown is surrounded by liars, i.e. Terra, Poppy, and Celeste.
  • I think Grimshaw had a crush on Isla way before the games began. I mean, he can become invisible and walk through walls. I feel like he definitely stalked Isla and liked her even before she knew him, which is really creepy. And I think he’s going to sacrifice himself or something for her.
The back cover with the words, “There are lies and liars all around you.” This quote comes from page 275 in chapter 36.

Book Review ⚠ Warning: Spoilers Ahead!

Chapter 53 was stunning!

I just finished Lightlark.

And… I did NOT see the stuff that happened coming! I now understand why the book bloggers were screaming in their Instagram stories, completely overwhelmed. Chapter 53 had me SHOOK. I really did get goosebumps. This was literally the face I was making: 😳

I could not keep the book down after the revelation! And with Oro and Grim both losing their powers, I expected it to end on a cliffhanger. The author could have, and I still would have raved about the ending, though upset and desperate for the sequel. Thankfully, she didn’t leave the readers hanging, discarding the impostor and bringing peace back on Lightlark.

Photo by Daniel Apodaca.

With all the new surprising twists, from Celeste being Aurora, the bondbreaker being bondmaker, Isla having both Nigthshade and Wildling power, the final chapters were like a series of blows to my head. Neither unpleasant nor violent, but just so striking as to make my eyes widen as I flipped the pages.

Another thing I found great was how the first pages of the novel tied to the final chapters. How the omitted scenes before the very first paragraphs were Isla’s lost memories. The way the story began with Grim’s influence on Isla’s memories without the readers knowing until the very last pages. I loved it!

There were some flaws, like the confusing world building, much repetition of certain vocabulary like “grinned,” “frowned,” and etc. And while it was marketed as something similar to The Hunger Games and A Court of Thorns and Roses, I found some parts of the novel similar to the Harry Potter series instead. Celeste’s demonstration where the rulers face their fears in the magical mirror was like a combination of the Mirror of Erised and Boggart from the Harry Potter series. Even the part where a mermaid/night creature pulls Isla further below the water reminded me of the merpeople in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.

Regardless, I’m happy to have read it! Just in time for…

The Lightlark Event in the SF Ferry Building!

Photo by Chad Peltola.

So, as mentioned before in my previous Lightlark post, there was going to be a national book tour of Lightlark. Today is actually the last day of the tour, with the final stop being the bookstore called, “The Ripped Bodice” in Los Angeles, CA. Each stop or independent bookstore was themed after one of the six realms of Lightlark with…

  • Brookline Booksmith in Boston, MA as Starling 🌟
  • The Georgia Center for the Book in Atlanta, GA as Sunling ☀
  • Anderson’s Bookshop in Chicago, IL as Skyling ☁
  • BookPeople in Austin, TX as Nightshade 🌃
  • Book Passage in San Francisco, CA as Moonling 🌙
  • The Ripped Bodice in Los Angeles, CA as Wildling 🥀

And I got to attend the Moonling-themed event at San Francisco’s iconic Ferry Building yesterday!

The Ferry Building in San Francisco! This iconic monument deserves a post of its own. Coming very soon. 😉

The Book Passage at the Ferry Building was literally the perfect Moonling, since it’s right by the water, and water is an element of the Moonlings. 🌊❄🌕

Book Passage inside the Ferry Building.
The view outside the bookstore. You can see the Treasure Island and Bay Bridge.

The people at the Book Passage even decorated the store with sparkly fringe curtain and balloons in the realm’s color:

The color of Lightlark’s Moon realm is white.

Before the Event

This being my first book event ever, I arrived like an hour early just in case. And because I was SO excited to meet the inspiring Alex Aster and Selene Velez, the BookToker who was invited to talk with her.

The event was going to start at 2PM with the check-in starting at 1:30, but people were already lined up outside waiting at around 1PM.

Waiting outside behind the Book Passage Cart on the back plaza by the water.
Look at this lovely chalkboard art Book Passage made for the Lightlark event!

When it was time for us to enter the bookstore, each person was given a free, pre-signed copy of Lightlark along with a special tour gift:

When we went inside one by one (with masks, of course), Alex Aster was already there! She was finishing up signing all the copies being given out at the event.

After she signed all the copies, Alex went outside for some minutes while the front area was reorganized. Seating near the front row facing the glistening decorations and with the water right outside the store, it truly felt like I was at a Moonling event.

You can actually see the water outside inside the store.

The Lightlark Event

The event officially began with an associate of Book Passage welcoming Alex and Selene into the bookstore. Once they were seated at the front, Alex and Selene were introduced, after which Selene interviewed Alex with some questions she prepared beforehand. She asked questions about Lightlark (i.e. which character Alex would be friends with in real life, which she wouldn’t be, what she liked about the Moon realm and its ruler, Cleo, and more) and about Alex’s literary journey as well as her writing process. Alex also asked Selene questions about her literary journey, the BookTok that changed her life, and more.

It was really inspiring to listen to them talk.

Towards the end of the event, the audience were allowed to ask questions, too. They asked really great questions, like how far Alex had gotten into writing the sequel (Lightlark Book 2) and what advice she would give to aspiring authors. After the event, each attendee was given a chance to meet Alex, get their pre-signed Lightlark personalized, and take photos with her. We were also allowed to talk to and take photos with Selene, too.

There were cupcakes provided by Alex’s publisher that we got to grab on our way out:

Chocolate and vanilla cupcakes at the event. 🧁

Conclusion

The Lightlark event in San Francisco was such a wonderful experience where everyone got to celebrate the novel’s launch, listen to inspiring women in the book industry, and meet fellow bibliophiles. Alex and Selene were friendly and sweet in real life, too, and it was a joy to get to talk to them. They’re both truly inspiring, with Alex bringing her novel (of stunning twists!) into life via BookTok after countless rejections and with Selene, who’s still in college, already making an impact in the book community.

Here’s a video of my first book event!


P.S. To learn more about Book Passage, click HERE. For more on San Francisco’s historic Ferry Building, click HERE.

P.P.S. Oh, and Lightlark is going to be made into a movie by Universal in partnership with Temple Hill! Visit The Hollywood Reporter or Alex Aster’s IG post for all the deets!

Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Novel #3: An Offer from a Gentleman

Photo by Annie Spratt.

I know that I bid adieu to the Bridgerton series after watching season 2. But I must write one more book review of the series, as I’ve already finished the third Bridgerton novel by Julia Quinn, An Offer from a Gentleman aka Benedict’s story.

I had read it before season 2 in hopes of being able to identify hints at Benedict’s upcoming love story. I wanted to be ready to recognize Sophie Beckett (Benedict’s future wife) when she showed up on the screen. To my disappointment, Netflix had hinted at neither the third novel nor Sophie. And Benedict will most likely NOT have the spotlight next season as they have switched up the order. Plus, they no longer do a good job focusing on the hero and the heroine (as shown in season 2), so I don’t expect his season to be that great either.

So despite my disappointment and lack of enthusiasm for Bridgerton, I present you a review of An Offer from a Gentleman since I already read it. And I’m happy to say that Julia Quinn’s third Bridgerton novel is better than the second season of Netflix’s Bridgerton.

An Offer from a Gentleman by Julia Quinn. Image from Amazon.

Here we go! 👇

Tale as Old as Time

Cinderella’s transformation from Disney’s Cinderella (1950). It’s the most beautifully animated scene ever! 💕
From https://giphy.com/explore/cinderella

An Offer from a Gentleman is a Cinderella retelling. But instead of Cinderella, we have Sophie Beckett, an illegitimate daughter of Richard Gunningworth, the Earl of Penwood. Though all the servants and the earl himself realize that she is his bastard daughter, he takes her in as his ward and remarries a woman named Araminta. When the earl passes away, Sophie is stuck with his new wife and her two daughters, Rosamund and Posy. Just like Cinderella, she is mistreated by her step family (except for Posy) and degraded to work as their servant (with no pay).

But one night, Sophie gets a chance to attend a grand masquerade ball hosted by Lady Bridgerton with the help of the housekeeper of Penwood, Mrs. Gibbons.

Instead of the fairy godmother, we have Mrs. Gibbons in An Offer from a Gentleman. Image: Disney Animation Studios.

There, she and Benedict Bridgerton (instead of the Prince) fall in love at first sight. Alas, Benedict loses Sophie after she escapes from the ball without telling him her name, and Sophie reluctantly returns back to servitude. With one pair of glove (instead of a glass slipper), the only clue he has to her identity, Benedict searches for his love in vain.

Prince Charming and Cinderella from Disney’s 1950 Cinderella. Image: Disney

Years later, Sophie and Benedict meet again when he saves her from getting raped by the son of her employer. But Benedict doesn’t recognize her (as they met wearing masks at his mother’s masquerade), and long story short, he falls in love with her again.

A Feel-Good Read

This Bridgerton retelling of Cinderella can’t be bad, as the fairytale has withstood the test of time. And Julia Quinn adds more fun to the classic tale by having Benedict torn between two women who actually are the same person. He can’t forget his “lady in silver” he met at the masquerade while he falls in love with a maid named Sophie Beckett.

Benedict (Luke Thompson) from Netflix’s Bridgerton season 2. Image from Bustle. Credits to Liam Daniel/Netflix

In chapter 11, Benedict kisses Sophie and is about to say that he’s never felt the way he did before, but Sophie doesn’t know how to feel about that since he’s kissed her before at the masquerade:

Dear God, was she jealous of herself?”

Page 171, An Offer from a Gentleman

I’ve never read about a heroine having to deal with self-jealousy. It was interesting! 😆

Quinn also adds more drama to the classic tale by exploring class differences of the Regency era and by having the heroine put in jail by her evil stepmother. But all ends well in the end and Sophie and Benedict have their happily ever-after.

Benedict was as unromantic as he could be when he asked Sophie to be his mistress, but considering the importance of class during the Regency era, it was realistic. (And he eventually redeems himself by choosing to marry Sophie despite what society would think of them.)

Lastly but not least, I liked Quinn’s writing of Posy Reiling, Sophie’s step sister. Unlike how both of Cinderella’s sisters are cruel in the original fairytale, Posy was kind hearted – just too young to help Sophie when they had lived together under Araminta. It was nice to see Posy save the day by helping Sophie AND stand against her abusive mother. I truly enjoyed reading the second epilogue where Posy gets her own happy ending.

Posy reminded me of Cinderella’s step sister Anastasia in the Cinderella sequels
where she becomes kind and meets someone she loves.
Disney’s Cinderella sequels – Cinderella II: Dreams Come True (2002) and Cinderella III: A Twist in Time (2007).

Benedict & Sophie

Benedict was my favorite Bridgerton brother, so this novel was even more pleasant to read. And it was wonderful to find out that he meets and marries Sophie, a beautiful, kind character based on Cinderella. She, along with Kate Sheffield/Sharma from The Viscount Who Loved Me are some of the most wonderful heroines I’ve read about.

Though I don’t expect much from the Netflix series anymore, I do hope they cast a great Sophie as they had done for Kate.

Who will be Sophie Beckett? (Photo by Felicity Lynn.)

Similar to Other Bridgerton Novels

Photo by Gülfer ERGİN.

Though I enjoyed the 3rd Bridgerton novel immensely, I did realize how similar it was to the other Bridgerton novels. After reading four Bridgerton novels, I noticed how Julia Quinn employs many of the same vocabulary, plot points, and male inner dialogue in her works.

She definitely likes to join couples together in the beginning with marriages of convenience (Daphne & Simon, Kate & Anthony, Eloise & Philip). All four heroines of the novels I’ve read are inexperienced with men (Penelope, Eloise, Kate, Sophie) and the couples always face problems in their relationships after 3/4 into the novels. And the male leads all sound the same when they’re angry. Their inner dialogues are, in my opinion, indistinguishable.

Portrait of the three Bridgerton sisters, Eloise, Daphne & Francesca.
From Netflix’s Bridgerton Instagram Page

Here’s a short comparison of the conflicts that arise three quarters into the novels:

🧡The Viscount Who Loved Me – Anthony and Kate didn’t really fight. But there was this big conflict when Anthony withdrew himself from his wife when he realized that he was falling in love with her. (Because he felt that he would die young like his father, he didn’t want to fall in love.)

💙An Offer from a Gentleman – Benedict and Sophie fought big time when Sophie refused to become his mistress & when Benedict discovered that Sophie was in fact, his “lady in silver.” These two conflicts arose at about the same time, around three quarters into the novel.

🤍Romancing Mister Bridgerton – It’s been a while since I read it, but I believe Colin and Penelope fought when Colin discovered that Penelope was Lady Whistledown and when he was jealous of her achievements (Goodness, Colin). Again, the fights happened after the halfway point.

💜To Sir Philip, With Love – I distinctly remember because I hated the novel so much: Eloise and Philip fought when Philip refused to discuss an important issue Eloise had brought up. (And he made a big fuss about it.)

And Anthony, Benedict, and Colin all have these bro-talks (not really talks but meet ups) with one another after which they realize how much they love their wives. After which the conflicts are resolved and the novels come to ends.

Portrait of the three older Bridgerton brothers. (Left to Right: Colin, Benedict & Anthony) From Netflix’s Bridgerton Instagram Page

In terms of repeated vocabulary, there’s the very modern interjection “Damn,” and the word “humbling.” And many more, but I can’t remember which pages they were on. Neither do I have the books with me anymore.

Here’s an enlightening, funny video created by a talented YouTuber named Julia Cudney, who’s read all 8 Bridgerton novels. She reviews and compares the novels excellently, with even spreadsheets!

Conclusion

I enjoyed reading An Offer from a Gentleman because…

1, It’s Benedict Bridgerton’s story.

2. It’s a Cinderella retelling – how could I not?

3. Hard-working, resilient & principled, Sophie Beckett is a lovely heroine!

4. Julia Quinn added fun changes to the classic fairytale.

Plus, there’s a masquerade ball! Photo by Julio Rionaldo.

Of the four Bridgerton books I’ve read, I’d say my favorites were 🤍 Romancing Mister Bridgerton (Book #4) and 💙 An Offer from a Gentleman (Book #3). The 2nd novel in the series, 🧡 The Viscount Who Loved Me was good and I enjoyed the enemies to lovers trope, but I really didn’t like the perverse persistence Anthony displayed in the novel. (Click HERE to read my review.) And of course, my least favorite was the 5th novel, 💜 To Sir Philip, With Love.

At this point, I’m ready to move on from Bridgerton. I’ve heard many praises about Francesca Bridgerton’s story, When He Was Wicked, from a number of Bridgerton fans, yet I’m not interested in Francesca enough to read her love story. (She barely has any lines in the Netflix show. Plus I read that she falls in love with her late husband’s cousin. It sounds awfully similar to To Sir Philip, With Love where Eloise falls in love with her late cousin’s husband, and knowing how much I disliked that novel…I’m not too excited for Francesca’s story. But maybe I’ll give it a go in the future.) Neither am I curious about the futures of the youngest Bridgertons, Hyacinth and Gregory. So…

So long, farewell Bridgerton! 👋


P.S. To read my review of the second season of Netflix’s Bridgerton, click HERE.

P.P.S. Check out these An Offer from a Gentleman covers from around the world! They’re beautiful😍 Visit Julia Quinn’s website HERE to see them all.


Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Season 2 Review: The Good & The Bad

Dear reader, I have just finished season 2 of Netflix’s Bridgerton, as you can tell by my introduction. And I have much to say about it, both good and bad.

I shall start with the good.

Image from bridgertonnetflix on Instagram.

The Good: Bridgerton Does It Again

👍Visuals & Music

The most anticipated series to return last month, Bridgerton season 2 brought back the Regency romance hype with its psuedo-Regency glam of glitters and florals. And really, this season was a feast for the eyes and ears as was the last. It had, once again, delightful set designs, fireworks and modern pop songs played by the orchestra.

👍Lovely Cast

^Above: Photos of the lovely Bridgerton cast shared by Netflix and the cast (Penelope & Daphne) on Instagram.

Though the much missed Duke of Hastings did not return, the rest of the cast did and were as likeable as ever. The lovely Bridgerton family, the always posh Queen Charlotte, sweet Penelope, pleasantly sharp-tongued Lady Danbury, and many from season 1 returned.

The handsome Jonathan Bailey stole the show this time, as this season is his season. (It’s based on the 2nd Bridgerton novel, The Viscount Who Loved Me, aka Anthony’s story). Though his acting can be sometimes overdone with visible trembles and wide-eyed expressions, I can’t imagine anyone else playing Anthony. Jonathan Bailey is Anthony Bridgerton! 😍

Jonathan Bailey as Anthony Bridgerton. Photo from Shondaland.
Credits to Liam Daniel/Netflix.

👍Wonderful New Characters

New characters from Julia Quinn’s novel, The Viscount Who Loved Me, were introduced in the second season: Kate Sharma (Simone Ashley), Edwina Sharma (Charithra Chandran), and Mary Sharma/Sheffield (Shelley Conn). As stated in my previous post, I think Simone Ashley was perfect for the role of Kate Sharma. She has this air of confidence about her and seems to possess the inner strength that Kate possesses. Charithra Chandran and Shelley Conn were wonderful as Edwina and Lady Mary, too, with their soft manners and lovely dispositions.

Simone Ashley, Charithra Chandran, and Shelley Conn (Image from Shondaland.)

And Simone Ashley is simply gorgeous! (From bridgertonnetflix on Instagram).

Characters not from Quinn’s novels were also introduced, including Lord Jack Featherington (Rupert Young) and Theo Sharpe (Calam Lynch). I found the new characters created by the Netflix team to be interesting additions to the ton (at least in the beginning). Especially Theo, who I’ll cover in just a bit.

And Newton the corgi was SO cute! He was a very good actor, too.

His smile! 🐶 Wish I could share this extremely adorable scene where Newton looks up at Anthony through a door, but due to copyright, I can’t share screenshots from the show. 🙁 Image from https://www.instagram.com/p/CbxwnHLJJo9/

Newton the corgi judging Anthony’s character from the official season 2 trailer.
Netflix seems to be smitten with Newton, too, based on their Twitter profile.

👍Charithra Chandran Shines as Edwina

Edwina Sharma (Image from Charithra Chandran’s Instagram page.)

But Charithra Chandran really shined beyond the “Edwina” written by Julia Quinn in episode 6 when she finds out the truth about Anthony and Kate during the marriage ceremony. She perfectly unleashes the rage and disappointment a girl would feel when she finds out that her fiancée loves her sister more than her. All the while standing at the altar before the priest. She was phenomenal!

And the way Edwina accepts the unacceptable and moves on by the end of the series really made me like the character more. The way Edwina is written by Netflix’s Bridgerton writers along with Charithra’s acting really made the actress stand out.

Photo from Allure.

👍Diverging from the Novel #1: Anthony’s Actions

The novel by Julia Quinn. Image from Amazon.

What really irritated me when reading The Viscount Who Loved Me was Anthony Bridgerton’s perverse persistence at marrying Edwina Sheffield. He 1) fell in love with Kate 2) acknowledged that he couldn’t keep himself away from her 3) then kissed her. But in the novel, he persistently and very perversely chooses to marry none other than Edwina, Kate’s sister even after kissing her.

If Anthony was convinced of his early death due to the traumatic death of his father and vowed to marry not out of love, he could have chosen someone else. Someone who didn’t have a sister he kissed and wanted to kiss repeatedly. And it didn’t make sense that he, a viscount, couldn’t find anyone in all of Britain pretty enough whom he didn’t love. He says in the show himself in the first episode that he looks for someone “tolerable, dutiful, [with] suitable enough hips for childbearing, and at least half a brain.” He even adds that having “at least half a brain” is “not so much a requirement but a preference.”

Anthony’s Actions Are Dishonorable to Say the Least

So it didn’t make sense in both the novel and the show that Anthony couldn’t find anyone in the entire kingdom, that he had to resort to the queen’s opinion and marry the diamond of the first water.

I mean, if he just had to marry the diamond of the first water, he could have married the next diamond of the first water after realizing that he was dreaming about the diamond’s sister. Even if he were to follow his father’s footsteps and die young, he had time considering the fact that his father passed away sometime into his marriage after Violet had given birth to all of the Bridgerton siblings (except for Hyacinth).

It was really perverse of Anthony to pursue the sister of someone he was attracted to, someone he kissed and wanted to kiss whenever they were alone together.

The Changes From the Novel

So I was really glad to see that Netflix scrapped away the perverse persistence shown in the novel and instead had Anthony fall in love, acknowledge that he wanted Kate, but only choose to move forward with the wedding because of Kate’s unwillingness to hurt her little sister.

And it was realistic to have Edwina fall in love with Anthony when he approached her with the intent of marrying her because Anthony is one of the most eligible bachelors of the season. He has good looks, good nature (despite being a rake), and a loving family. But the novel’s down-to-earth Edwina doesn’t fall for him in the least. She allows herself to be courted by Anthony even when she isn’t interested because of her family’s economic situation. She remains uninterested in him and wishes him for Kate after quickly realizing that something is between the two. Such plot works, too. And it is rather pleasant not to witness two sisters fall for the same guy. But I think it is much more realistic to have the younger sister be naïvely romantic and fall in love with a highly distinguished gentleman courting her publicly.

👍Diverging from the Novel #2: Theo Sharpe

Honestly, I wish Eloise Bridgerton ends up with Theo, because he is a much, MUCH better match for her than Sir Philip Crane. Not only are they cute together, but also Theo treats Eloise better. In the few minutes shown in the series, Theo sets aside books Eloise might like and listens to what she has to say. This is so much better than Sir Philip, who in To Sir Philip, With Love chooses Eloise as his wife just so she can take care of his kids while he does what he wants to do (he actually admits it himself) and doesn’t listen to what she has to say. I believe he calls her noisy and loud- I don’t have the book with me at the moment so I can’t give the exact page numbers. But I do clearly remember thinking that Eloise deserved someone better than him after reading the novel. <For the full review of To Sir Philip, With Love, click HERE.>

Eloise and Theo. Image from TV Insider, credits to Liam Daniel/Netflix.

I hope Netflix’s Bridgerton stays away from the novel for Eloise’s story. Even the Philip before he loses Marina seem a totally wrong match for Eloise. (It was suffocating to watch poor Marina in her loveless marriage with Sir Philip in Episode 4 of Season 2).

Speaking of Philip, I’ll move onto what was bad about Bridgerton season 2.

The Bad: Bridgerton Is Only Tolerable

After the second season, I think my sentiments toward the Netflix sensation is as Anthony had described what he wanted his wife to be: “tolerable.” Bridgerton season 2 was tolerable, but not as fun as it had once been. And I honestly have better things to watch. Here are my reasons:

👎Too Much Going On

Bridgerton season 2 was fast-paced with much happening to many different characters. Though the focus was on Anthony Bridgerton and Kate Sharma, I think this season was less focused than the last. Season 1 was all about Daphne Bridgerton and Simon Bassett, with the lives of those around them being touched upon. And the only hint at the next season was Anthony declaring that he’ll get himself a wife he doesn’t love. Season 2 was busy making sure that Anthony and Kate were falling in love while Anthony was courting Edwina, all the while introducing new characters and keeping in touch with old characters. All this happening while the show was setting up the stage for the next two scheduled seasons (with Eloise finding out that Penelope was Lady Whistledown & etc.)

Photo by Judson Moore.

👎Unnecessary Appearances

Collin’s visit to Marina for Sir Philip Crane’s appearance was unnecessary. Unpleasant, even. And why is Will appearing so much when even the Duke himself isn’t? Moving on to the newest addition to the Featheringtons: Cousin Jack. Though Cousin Jack was an interesting add to the cast in the beginning, his scheme turned out to be a waste of screen time. He is even scheduled to go back to America. Why was he even introduced then? Theo, too. He looked so good with Eloise, but he and Eloise seem to have ended.

To be honest, the season wouldn’t have been much different if these characters hadn’t appeared/reappeared.

👎Trying to Do Too Much

I think Bridgerton season 2 was trying to do too much at once compared to season 1 while trying to let all side and minor protagonists have their moments (even Will with his new business). They even added another swing scene with Benedict and Eloise encouraging one another. Sweet scene, but once is enough, I think, for a TV series with only 8 episodes per season.

Season 1 was like a feast with the main dish placed in the middle with side dishes not getting in the way. Season 2 had its table overloaded with food, with the main dish being slightly larger than the side dishes that all clamored for its spot.

👎Simon’s Absence

Regé-Jean Page who plays Simon Bassett, the Duke of Hastings, did not return for the second season. Much to many, many fans’ dismay, he left after being largely responsible for the show’s massive success in season 1. And this is one of the many reasons why the second season was only tolerable.

Daphne (Phoebe Dynevor) and Simon (Regé-Jean Page) from season 1.
(Image from The Guardian. Credits Liam Daniel/Netflix via AP.)

His absence created a large hole in the plot. For instance, it didn’t make any sense for Simon to not attend Anthony Bridgerton and Edwina Sharma’s wedding (that was cancelled). He was Daphne Bridgerton’s loving husband and Anthony’s close friend. Yet, he was nowhere to be found at the wedding where even the queen was in attendance. His absence made it seem (unintentionally) that Daphne’s marriage was in trouble again after all the other troubles from season 1.

(This article from ScreenRant even says the holes left by Simon were so large in season 2 that killing off the character would have been better for the plot. Really, Simon was such an important character to not return in season 2.)

Regé-Jean Page’s absence really took a toll on Bridgerton, as the actor was also the one who made the series so alluring and addictive.

The ever-so-handsome Regé-Jean Page.
Photo from People.

👎You’re Not Color-Blind, Shondaland

Photo by Leonardo Burgos.

“Shondaland thinks that it’s very important that people see themselves reflected on screen,” says Kathryn. “I think that’s how you truly connect to your audience and those stories.”…

Bridgerton received widespread publicity for so-called ‘colour-blind casting’ in a genre traditionally populated by white actors, but Kathryn disagrees with the use of that term.

“It’s not colour-blind casting, it’s colour-conscious casting. I’m very much playing a mixed race modiste … nobody’s blind to the fact that I am the colour that I am in this story.”

– Kathryn Drysdale (Madame Delacroix)’s interview on The Afternoon Show (The BBC Scotland article can be viewed HERE).

The South Asian representation shown in this season was wonderful. But if the show truly were color blind, why are there such little/no representation of Meso and South American, Middle Eastern, East Asian and Southeast Asians? There have been two seasons, and about half of the cast are Caucasian while the other half African. And one can see that all the recurring characters that aren’t in the novel are either African or Caucasian, too. Minor side characters from the novel are turned into major roles and given to African actors and actresses, namely Lady Danbury, Queen Charlotte, and Marina Thompson.

Nothing is wrong with all this. It’s just that the “color blind” or the “color-conscious” (as explained by actress Kathryn Drysdale) label and advertisement the show uses is inaccurate and really misleading.

Dear Shondaland, you’re not color-blind. Neither are you color-conscious. You have mostly black & white vision.

👎Diverged Too Far

Photo by Jens Lelie.

By the end of the 2nd season, Netflix’s Bridgerton seems to declare that it will be an entirely separate work from Julia Quinn’s Bridgerton novels. Anthony and Kate just got married and already Eloise had discovered that Lady Whistledown is actually her best friend Penelope Featherington.

I wish Netflix stuck to Quinn’s novels while omitting/changing the parts that don’t work. For instance, the scene where Daphne violates Simon could have been scrapped out as pointed out by many in the first season.

YouTuber Jack Edwards’s review of the first Bridgerton novel. He is one of the many who have pointed out that the controversial scene from the book could have been removed from the first season.

👎Left Out the Good Parts

Kate and Anthony’s love story could have been explored more as the novel does. The wonderful scenes where Anthony and Kate help each other face their traumas and heal together were largely missing, as Kate’s fear of lightnings were nonexistent in the show. And the scene where the soprano Siena and Anthony are alone together with Kate hiding under his desk would have been really interesting (and relevant!). If the showrunners wanted to reintroduce old characters from season 1, Siena should have reappeared for Anthony’s story, not Marina, Philip, Will, Alice, etc. She was his lover he proposed to in the previous season!!! (And a major reason why he forgoes love in the second season!)

👎Unnecessary Change

Snapshot of the Bridgerton novels by Julia Quinn in order from left to right. From Google search.

Julia Quinn’s timeline for the novels worked. The transition from one sibling to another in alphabetical order following Daphne worked. But Netflix seems to have thrown that out, as Eloise already knows who Lady Whistledown is, and this is Romancing Mister Bridgerton stuff. (Though they did a better job writing Eloise’s reaction to the revelation than Julia Quinn. Eloise in one of the 2nd epilogues doesn’t really reacts to/cares about her friend being the secret writer.)

It would have been better to stick to one sibling’s story per season, as Quinn’s novels do.

I have more negative things to say about the second season (e.g. characters like Eloise losing their charms), but I’ll stop here. The post is long enough.

It Would Have Been Better If…

I think the second season would have been better if it had stuck to the novel while changing/omitting Quinn’s weak points. It would have been a solid second season if they had focused on Anthony and Kate, with little bits on the surrounding characters and hints at Benedict’s story. They could have introduced Sophie Beckett of all people! It was a real disappointment that Sophie wasn’t introduced while the antagonist the protagonist of the fifth novel had his screen time. And while some random Lord Featherington aka “Cousin Jack” appeared in every episode.

If the Netflix team had…

  1. focused on Kate and Anthony’s love story (sticking to Julia Quinn’s plot but improving it)
  2. left out all the unnecessary moments showing Cousin Jack, Theo, Will, Alice, and etc.
  3. hinted at the 3rd novel while focusing on the 2nd (as the first season had focused on the 1st while hinting at 2nd) instead of setting the stage for the 4th and 5th novels,

the second season would have been even better than the first, as there wouldn’t have been the controversial scene of season 1.

Conclusion

Season 2 tried to include too many things. Image by Joanna Kosinska.

Bridgerton season 2 was a tolerable watch. A lot was happening, with mess upon mess the characters had to deal with (i.e. scandals, broken marriage, broken friendship, heartbreaks & more). But with so much going on, the show was all over the place. I have a feeling that Netflix will try to jam-pack Julia Quinn’s 4th and 5th novels (and maybe 3rd & 6th too?) all in the next two seasons. Who knows? But I definitely felt that season 2 was less focused than the last.

Despite the controversial scene, Season 1 was much more focused than Season 2. Image from Seventeen.

Farewell, Bridgerton

Bridgerton has its strong and weak points. And the show can’t satisfy everyone. So after having watched the second season that was scattered all over the place, I plan to move on from Bridgerton. I might look up what happens in the next two seasons in the future. But I definitely wouldn’t be as excited for its return as I had been for this season (i.e. draw fanarts).

I hereby end my review with a video of Nicola Coughlan (Penelope) and Claudia Jessie (Eloise) giving a tour of the Bridgerton sets:


P.S. To read my review of the 2nd Bridgerton novel, The Viscount Who Loved Me, aka Anthony’s story, click HERE.

P.P.S. Here are some season 2 reviews I found to be insightful:

  • Review by YouTuber Jessen Reads Romance:

Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Season 2 Fan Art

Just 10 More Days

The countdown has really begun for Netflix’s Bridgerton Season 2! Just 10 more days until the series return with Julia Quinn’s second Bridgerton novel, The Viscount Who Loved Me.

As mentioned in my previous post, I fell hard for the Bridgerton series. The characters written by Julia Quinn are interesting and fun to read about, and one cannot help but like the cast, who individually and as a group literally shine on screen. And the cast playing the Bridgerton family really look and feel like family. They’re brilliant! 🤩

And the music, the costumes, and just the overall magic of everything coming together.. Bridgerton was a feast to behold and I can tell by the official trailer and clips that it still will be in 2022.

Keep Calm & Make Fan Art

Anyways, though I should have been wrapping up my third Bridgerton novel, I could not help but make a fan art of the upcoming season. Though delightful as it is to read about Benedict Bridgerton and Sophie Beckett’s story, I’m too excited to NOT make fan art at this point.

So I present you my very own fan art of Bridgerton Season 2, Kate & Anthony inside Pall Mall balls:

It was a bit difficult to depict the beautiful Simone Ashley and handsome Anthony Bailey as accurately as I could, but fun nonetheless. 😉

HERE is another official trailer of Bridgerton Season 2 from Netflix!

*To read about my review of Bridgerton novel #2, The Viscount Who Loved Me, click HERE.

**To visit the official website of author Julia Quinn, click HERE.


Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Novel #2: The Viscount Who Loved Me

Photo by Abigail Keenan. (Image lightened).

I’m happy to announce that I just finished the second Bridgerton novel by Julia Quinn, The Viscount Who Loved Me. I was worried about not finishing on time by March 25th, which is when Netflix’s Bridgerton returns with Anthony’s story. In other words, when The Viscount Who Loved Me debuts on Netflix. I honestly can’t wait to watch the new season and compare the show to the novel! 😆

But before any of that, here is my take on The Viscount Who Loved Me.

A Fun Read

As pointed out, this Bridgerton novel is all about Anthony Bridgerton and his love interest, Katharine (Kate) Sheffield.

It’s about how Anthony, convinced that he will die at an early age as his beloved father had, vows to marry out of everything except love. He chooses to marry a decent, intelligent-enough young lady named Edwina, who is the season’s diamond of the first water. But he gradually falls in love with her sister, Kate, who distrusts and detests him with all her might.

Image of The Viscount Who Loved Me from Amazon.

I sincerely enjoyed the enemies-to-lovers trope. It really is entertaining to watch two people who hate each other fall in love. The Pall Mall scene where Kate beats Anthony by hitting his ball into the lake is golden! 😁 I love how their rivalry continues well into their marriage, as shown in the second epilogue.

Image from Netflix’s official Bridgerton Instagram page. Can’t wait for the Pall Mall games!

Anthony & Kate

The new cover of The Viscount Who Loved Me from Amazon.

But what I really appreciated was reading Anthony and Kate help each other overcome their traumas. I think Julia Quinn did a great job exploring both Kate’s and Anthony’s demons.

At first I couldn’t believe the lengths Anthony took to avoid love. His adamant conviction of a premature death was hard to wrap my head around. But the more I read, the more plausible it all became. I was further convinced after reading the author’s note, which explains that Anthony’s reaction to his father’s early death is something that is common among men.

Young Anthony and his father Edmund Bridgerton, to be played by Rupert Evans. Image: Netflix.

The Viscount Who Loved Me is a pleasant read. It explores deep topics like loss, trauma, and their lasting effects. But unlike To Sir Philip, With Love, this novel shows its protagonists overcoming their wounds together. Whereas Sir Philip expects Eloise to solve all his problems (and she does), Anthony and Kate solve their problems together by being there for each other.

They each face their fears while standing next to one another. Anthony and Kate are such a lovely couple who become stronger together. It has been wonderful reading about their story. 💖

Sneak peek photo from Shondaland! Image: Liam Daniel/Netflix.

Pet Peeve

Despite my compliments, there was something that bothered me while reading the novel. It was the fact that even after falling for Kate and kissing her in his study in chapter 7, Anthony still pursues after her sister Edwina.

In the beginning, I was somewhat able to understand his decision to marry Edwina and the lengths he took to avoid love. But after kissing his future sister-in-law, it sounded incredibly weird. Like, there are other women out there he can marry not out of love. It just boggled my mind that Anthony would continue to woo Edwina after kissing Kate and thinking that she just “felt right.” (pg 109).

New characters for season 2: Kate Sharma (Simone Ashley), Mary Sharma (Shelley Conn), and Edwina Sharma (Charithra Chandran). The casting is perfect! Image: Netflix.

Anthony and Kate’s story all works out in the end, but I found this to be extremely perverse of Anthony. And just cruel to Kate.

Anthony Bridgerton (Jonathan Bailey) and Kate Sharma (Simone Ashley). Photo from Shondaland. Image: Netflix.

Netflix’s Bridgerton Season 2

Kate Sharma, Newton the Corgi, and Edwina Sharma. Image: Liam Daniel/Netflix.

I’m truly glad to have finished the novel on time. I’m now ready to watch the next season of Bridgerton on Netflix! I can already tell that Jonathan Bailey and Simone Ashley are going to be incredible together as Anthony Bridgerton and Kate Sharma. (They changed her surname from Sheffield to Sharma for diversity purposes.) Here’s the official teaser:

Though she doesn’t exactly fit the physical descriptions written in the novel, Simone Ashley totally has Kate Sheffield vibes. I think she’s going to be stellar like Regé Jean Page was as Simon Bassett, Duke of Hastings.

It sucks that Regé Jean Page won’t come back for the second season…
He will be dearly missed! 😥 Image from Variety, by Liam Daniel/Netflix.

Well, now I’m off for the third novel, An Offer From A Gentleman! 🥿✨✨✨


Check out my post on the 4th Bridgerton novel, Romancing Mister Bridgerton right HERE.

For my review of the 5th Bridgerton novel, To Sir Philip, With Love, click HERE.

Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Novel #5: To Sir Philip, With Love

So I finished To Sir Philip, With Love, aka Eloise’s story today and… I have a complaint quite a few complaints.

#1) Philip

It has been written in the novel that Philip Crane is a good man. He is described as a “nice” and “honorable” man. To be sure, he is: he married his late brother’s to-be bride out of responsibility and took utmost care of her (Marina Thompson) even though neither she nor he loved one another. And considering everything Philip had gone through from a traumatic childhood (violent, toxic father) and the early death of his mother to a loveless marriage with a suicidal wife who, in a way, succeeds in her attempt to end her life…One cannot help but feel deep empathy towards the man who hides in his greenhouse to avoid further problems in life (i.e. his twins).

Nevertheless, that does not change the fact that he is one of the worst guys to marry for a young heroine who has lived a life protected by her loving family. Eloise looked for romance while he, as stated throughout the book, looked for a problem-solver, mother to his twins, housekeeper and a bedwarmer. The witty Bridgerton sibling who dreamed for romance ended up with her late cousin’s husband who had personal problems he needed to address with a psychiatrist. And his two children.

#2) Philip Crane

I continued reading To Sir Philip, With Love to see how things would work out. And it does work out. Eloise is extremely happy and content, as are Philip and his two children, Oliver and Amanda. It all works out magically. But life doesn’t work out so magically like that, especially when a young girl (28 but inexperienced and naïve) makes the mistake of running away from home to marry her pen pal she never even saw once in her life.

And that Pen Pal turns out to be a man so hurt emotionally and psychologically that he can’t and won’t manage his children. And he had talked about marriage in hopes that his new wife would solve all his problems.

#3) Sir Philip Crane

But what really made me dislike Sir Philip Crane was when he says this:

You said we have a problem,” he repeated, his voice so low and forceful she didn’t think he’d hear another interruption even if she tried. “But until you live through what I lived through,” he continued, “until you’ve been trapped in a hopeless marriage, to a hopeless spouse, until you’ve gone to bed alone for years wishing for nothing more than the touch of another human being.

He turned around, stepped toward her, his eyes alight with a fire that humbled her. “Until you’ve lived through all that,” he said, “don’t you ever complain about what we have. Because to me… to me…” He choked on the words, but barely paused before he continued. “This – us – is heaven. And I can’t bear to to hear you say otherwise.”

Philip Crane to Eloise Bridgerton on page 353 of To Sir Philip, With Love by Julia Quinn.

But they did have a problem. When Eloise pointed out that they needed to have a conversation about their twins’ nurse (who turned out to be hurting them beyond reason with a book), Philip avoided the conversation and dumped all responsibility on Eloise as he was more interested in her than solving problems together as husband and wife. It was a problem.

Eloise had pointed out a problem. And here was Philip, telling her later to don’t “ever complain” about their marriage… I mean, I get where he is coming from as he is a man who’s been in much pain from a loveless, hopeless marriage, but he ought to consider from her perspective, too. Or any perspective that does not involve self-pity.

Conclusion

As one of my favorite Bridgerton siblings is Eloise, I think I may be a bit harsh on Sir Philip Crane. The novel portrays him as a good, honorable man, and I do think the man who’s been through so much trauma and pain is indeed good and honorable. Yet it was depressing to discover that he was the “one” for Eloise Bridgerton.

Alas, everything works out in the end (like magic). Eloise Bridgerton is even described as being so happy and in love that she cries. Sir Philip Crane and Eloise Bridgerton feel lucky to have found one another. That’s wonderful.

But from my limited knowledge and experience, I find it hard to believe that such magic is possible. Because in the world that I live in, a 28-year-old woman who rashly marries her late cousin’s husband/Pen Pal friend she’d never seen in her life, who becomes his twins’ stepmother, does not have everything work out so magically.

And though the novel is set in the Regency Era, Eloise and Philip’s love story seems highly implausible. To Sir Philip, With Love felt more fictional than fictions can be.

Beautiful photo by Євгенія Височина.

I really hope Netflix doesn’t make Eloise Bridgerton (played by Claudia Jessie) settle for Sir Philip Crane (played by Chris Fulton). They should keep changing the plot as they’ve done in Season 2.

To read about Penelope’s story of the Bridgerton novels, click HERE. It’s way better.

P.S. Tippi Studio has created some of the most beautiful Bridgerton fan arts – check out the artist’s Eloise on Instagram HERE!


Posted on Leave a comment

Bridgerton Novel #4: Romancing Mister Bridgerton

Like the rest of the ton who watched Netflix’s first season of Bridgerton, I fell prey to the addictive series. And I fell hard, looking up details for the next season once season 1 ended ended and starting to devour the original novels written by Julia Quinn. Just a week ago, I finished reading Brigerton novel #4, Romancing Mister Bridgerton, instead of reading The Duke & I and The Viscount Who Loved Me first as would have be in order and proper.

I made the transgression as I already saw the story of Daphne and Simon via Netflix and preferred to read their story when I didn’t remember all the details. And I wanted to find out about Penelope’s fate more so than Anthony’s. Though I adored Anthony Bridgerton (played by Anthony Bailey) and was curious about his happy ending,

1) Penelope Featherington was such a lovable character (one of my favorites in Bridgerton) played by Nicola Coughlan,

2) and she’s Lady Whistledown.

So I skipped over a couple of novels and started binge-reading Romancing Mister Bridgerton. And I have no regrets whatsoever!

Penelope & Colin’s Story

It’s an entire book devoted to Penelope Featherington, a close friend of the Bridgerton family aka the BFF of Eloise Bridgerton, and her life-long crush who never really paid any attention to her: Colin Bridgerton. At least not romantically. It details how the two fall in love. Or rather, it shows how they truly get to know each other beyond mere acquaintances and become each other’s soulmates.

Julia Quinn does such a lovely job showing the two family friends become lovers that the novel leaves you smiling at the end. But I must add that like the Netflix series, it’s definitely not for young readers.

On Bridgerton

The biggest reason I started watching Bridgerton was because I had heard that it was set in the Regency Era. And although I truly adore all things Regency, Georgian, and Austenian, I was equally fascinated by the Netflix series’s unhistorical elements: the diverse cast and the pleasantly garish costumes. It was such a daring, interesting move made by the production/creative team.

And as proven by the countless fans including myself, it turned out to be refreshingly enjoyable and successful!

One thing that drew me further into the series was the excellent choice of the cast. They’re all excellent actors and actresses – I was able to see that while watching the series. But after reading Quinn’s novels, I can’t help but wonder what a great job they did with the casting. Nicola Coughlan is Penelope Featherington; Luke Newton is Colin Bridgerton. And everyone else, too, are perfect portrayals of the fictional characters of the Bridgerton world.

Not to mention the chemistry amongst the cast! Whether it be amongst the Bridgerton siblings or between Simon Bassett and Daphne Bridgerton, their relationships are incredibly believable.

🐝🐝🐝

More to Come

Beautiful photograph by Katherine Hanlon.

After finishing Romancing Mister Bridgerton, I am now almost done with Eloise’s story, To Sir Philip, With Love. I must admit I prefer Penelope and Colin’s story over Eloise and Philip’s story. Where the former’s deal with friendship, love, and secrets, the latter’s deals with heavier topics like suicide, loss, childhood trauma, and parenthood in addition to love. And Sir Philip Crane is unbearable most of the time as opposed to Colin who becomes intolerable a few times (like when he was jealous of Penelope’s talent & success). Though one must consider that Philip has gone through so much, I can’t help but think that Eloise, the witty, unique heroine, deserves someone better.

I can’t wait to read the rest of the Bridgerton novels, especially Benedict’s story, An Offer from a Gentleman, as Benedict is one of my favorite characters (after Penelope and Eloise). But I’ve read someone say that in the novel Benedict asks his love interest, Sophie Beckett, to become his mistress and that…is unromantic to say the least.

Well, season 2 starts March 25th 2022! Click HERE for the first look showing Anthony Bridgerton and Kate Sharma (Kate Sheffield in Quinn’s book, The Viscount Who Loved Me). 😍